In an alimony case where the requesting party fails to provide supporting financial documents, a court may impute reasonable expenses based on circumstantial and testimonial evidence.

May 24, 2018

In a previous Utah Supreme Court case of Dahl v. Dahl, 2015 UT 79, the court rule in the facts of that case, Wife failed to show but providing documentary support that she had a financial need that would support an award of alimony. (She also was receiving substantial assets in the property settlement). This is a common contention in alimony trials–that a party fails to provide receipts, bank records, statement, contracts or other evidence of his or her expenses to show that they have a need for alimony. And because a court is generally constrained to limit an award of alimony to a recipient’s need (their proven budget), a lack of documentation provided at trial by the recipient spouse is often used to argue and limit or reduce an alimony award. However, in this court of appeals case, Munos v. Carlos, No. 20161013-CA, Filed May 24, 2018, the court ruled that it believed the standard of the Utah Supreme Court under Dahl is that court may impute or assume reasonable expenses if there is some evidence of the expenses and the expenses are otherwise reasonable. The court of appeals explained, “…courts may impute figures where there is insufficient evidence of one of the statutory alimony factors.” Dahl. ¶ 116 (internal quotation omitted). Thus, a court can make findings related to the statutory alimony factors without supporting financial documents and can impute reasonable expenses based on circumstantial or testimonial evidence.

September 27, 2018
Attorney Fees Awarded on the Basis of One Party’s Bad Faith Conduct Cannot Be Awarded if the Litigation was Not Entirely Meritless

In a case brought by a father in which the court ruled against him and awarded attorney fees, the Court […]

Read More
April 12, 2018
A Petition to Modify Custody Requires a “Substantial and Material Change of Circumstances” Whereas a Request to Modify Parent Time Only May Only Require a “Change of Circumstances”

In this case, at the time of trial, the parties lived about 60 minutes apart. The court found that the […]

Read More
December 28, 2018
Does Separate Property Become Marital Property When Titled as Joint Tenants? It Depends…

This is an appeal from a district court’s division of property and award of alimony in the aftermath of a […]

Read More
envelopephone-handsetmap-markermagnifiercrossmenuarrow-up-circle